In 1991, the UK government amended the Veterinary Surgeons Act, thereby prohibiting the docking of dog's tails by lay persons. Since then, only qualified registered veterinary surgeons are, by law, allowed to dock. The current legal status of the tail docking of dogs is that tail docking is restricted and illegal (since the Animal Welfare Act of 2007), with the exception of some breeds of working dogs.
In England the following can be docked:
2.
Spaniels of any type or combination of types.
3. Terriers of any type or combination of
types.
Arguments for the ban
-Prior to the 1991 law, amateurs
were doing the job badly and inflicting unnecessary pain and injury to the
young dogs.
-Docking was being performed for
cosmetic purposes as oppose to justified medical or work-related reasons.
-The procedure can be incredibly
painful and this pain can result in trauma for the dogs.
It is now illegal for docked dogs to be shown in
open/championship dog shows, because since April 2011 docking is against the
breed standard.
Arguments against the ban
-Some people believe that the damage caused to the tails of
working dogs which are not docked at a young age, is greater than the docking
itself would have been. For example, if a working dog injures its tail during a
hunt resulting in the need for amputation, this amputation at an older age is
likely to be far more painful and expensive than an early tail dock would have
been.
-The tail of a dog is not essential for it to function in
life.
(Information from: CBD, wiki, Kennel Club, DEFRA and the BVA)
No comments:
Post a Comment